September 4, 2026
Dorothy Denetclaw and Matt Fitzsimons, authors of The Sons of Gunshooter: A Navajo Resistance Story, spoke at the New Mexico History Museum in Santa Fe on August 15, 2026, as part of Indian Market Week. Dorothy Denetclaw is Tótsohnii born for Tł’ááschí’í. She has lived in Indian Wells, Arizona her whole life. Matt Fitzsimons is a former newspaper reporter and the author of The Counterfeiters of Bosque Redondo: Slavery, Silver, and the U.S. War Against the Navajo Nation. He lives in San Diego, California, and is a member of the Diné Studies Conference, based in Window Rock, Arizona.
Fitzsimons began the presentation by talking about The Hubbell Trading Post, a major setting in The Sons of Gunshooter, describing Hubbell’s exploitation of Navajo artists, as well as what happened to Denetclaw’s family: “A fuller history besides showing wrongdoing allows us to recognize resistance, survival, and better ways of doing things in the future…I mean, there’s all this terrible stuff that happened to Dorothy’s family, but they got through it time and time again. You know, the Hubbells went bankrupt and Dorothy’s family is out there today selling art on the plaza. You know, it’s a good story. It’s a happy story. I don’t know why we’re afraid to be honest with tourists about it.”
Watch the fascinating presentation in the video here.
About the book:
In 1919, the brother of one of the West’s most famous Indian traders was shot to death in a remote corner of the Navajo Nation.
Part history, part true crime, The Sons of Gunshooter reexamines the killing and subsequent murder trial, while simultaneously embedding the story in a much larger saga of colonization and resistance. The result is a book that’s sweeping in its scope and surgical in its approach. Rewinding the clock to 1868, the authors follow the intertwining paths of two families to offer a riveting, deeply personal account that has been hailed as “a new way of doing historiography.”
One of the authors is a descendant of participants in the case; the other is an investigative journalist. By merging Diné oral traditions with archival evidence, they succeed in upending one false narrative after another.